Allerton is the only Mayflower passenger known to have lived in what is now New York City. After leaving Plymouth in the 1630s over financial and religious disagreements, he settled in Dutch New Amsterdam (Lower Manhattan) by 1639. He became one of the city's wealthiest merchants, built a warehouse and dock along the East River near modern-day Pearl Street, and was appointed to the "Eight Men," an early citizen advisory council that pushed for settler self-government.