In early 1787 Robert, who had since joined the New York Manumission Society and moved to Peck Slip, discovered what had happened to Liss. He confronted Alexander Robertson, obtained details of Liss’s enslavement by Palmes, and repurchased 4-year-old Harry back. He brought Harry to Oyster Bay to his parents’ home. He then wrote letters to Charleston merchants, requesting their assistance in re-purchasing Liss and bringing her back to New York.
Despite several complications, including a 1786 New York law prohibiting the sale of slaves across state lines, it appears Liss was smuggled back to Oyster Bay in the early summer of 1787.
In November 1789 Liss was a member of the Baptist Church of Oyster Bay listed as “Elizabeth, a Black woman.” She may also be the person listed as “Free Elizabeth,” recorded in the 1790 Census employed at a manor called “Fort Neck House” in what is now Massapequa, New York.