On her third try, Sarah married Captain William Kidd. Admittedly, they seem to have filed for a marriage license several days after Oort died causing some of their neighbors to wonder about the convenient timing. It seems to have been a love match. They became solid citizens, had two daughters. When he got a commission as a privateer, he left for Africa, and returned after a couple of raids with enough treasure to make him the richest man in the colonies. He also tried to navigate the fallout, caching some of his loot in multiple locations from a tree in Long Island to an apron in New England and and trying to appease his fickle patrons who brought him down on what were probably trumped up charges. Sarah was loyal enough to follow him to Boston and managed to get arrested and imprisoned in Stone Prison.