In the spring of 1832, Lewis Tappan and William Green rented the building, which was one of NYC's largest public halls.. They offered it to the Presbyterian minister Charles Grandison Finney, a radical abolitionist who converted it into the Broadway Tabernacle/Free Presbyterian Chatham Street Chapel. The Tappan brothers also used the chapel for abolitionist meetings.
In its later years, the church became a hotel. The building has since been demolished.